Ultra Lux Realty

Lux South Florida Real Estate

The White-Glove Standard in Lux Real Estate Based in Sunny Isles Beach, delivering exceptional buying, selling, leasing, and property management services across South Florida.

Salem House, Sunny Isles Beach: What Buyers Should Check

Salem House, Sunny Isles Beach — 3-story condos at 251 172nd St

Salem House is a small three-story low-rise at 251 172nd Street, completed in 1969, with 104 residences — mostly one-bedroom, one-bath homes of 564 square feet, plus a 412-square-foot studio — and one of the lowest-priced ways into Sunny Isles Beach, with a community pool, laundry facilities, and one assigned parking space per residence, one block from the beach and within walking distance of restaurants, supermarkets, and shopping. Two things a buyer must look into before anything else, because the sources conflict on both: the rental rules — some listing copy says the building allows and approves short-term rentals including Airbnb, while the MLS minimum-lease fields range from 120 days to 365 days depending on the unit — so verify the lease rules in the association documents before buying for income; and the dues, which range from $268 to $578 a month across listings, so the adopted budget is the document that matters. Pets look mostly allowed with restrictions — several MLS records cap them at 20 lbs — but that is listing data, not an association document. The market is thin: one residence was for sale in early November 2026 asking $290,000, and seven sales have closed since 2021, the most recent in July 2025 at $282,000.

The facts

  • Address: 251 172nd St, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160.
  • Completed: 1969.
  • Stories: 3.
  • Residences: 104.
  • Unit mix: one-bedroom, one-bath residences of 564 sq ft standard; studio (0-bed) of 412 sq ft.
  • Waterfront: not waterfront; one block from the beach.
  • Parking: 1 assigned parking space.
  • Association: Salem House Condo.

Amenities and day-to-day living

Salem House runs a deliberately small program: a community pool, laundry facilities, and one assigned parking space per residence. There is no gym, clubhouse, valet, or beach service — the amenity list is the pool and the laundry room — and the building sits one block from the beach, within walking distance of restaurants, supermarkets, shopping, and everyday conveniences. The market is thin and low-priced: one residence was for sale in early November 2026 asking $290,000 ($514 per sq ft), one was for rent at $1,700 a month, seven sales have closed since 2021 with the most recent in July 2025 (unit #209 at $282,000), and one lease was signed in the last 12 months at $1,600 a month. Rentals are visibly listed at $1,700 to $2,100 a month, and prospective tenants must be approved by both the landlord and the condominium association before occupancy, per listing copy. Owner-occupancy is low at 17% per county records, which a lender will want confirmed before closing.

What to check before you buy

  • Monthly cost — the dues vary widely across listings; confirm them against the adopted budget. MLS records give $578 a month (unit #112, February 2026), $550 a month (unit #209, July 2025), $434 a month (unit #213, November 2026), $406 a month (unit #330), and $268–$269 a month in older records. All are listing-derived, not the adopted budget, and the spread suggests dues have moved over time or vary by unit. The fee is stated to include common areas, maintenance of the grounds, sewer, trash, and water (unit #209), and insurance, sewer, water, and common areas (unit #213). Confirm the dues for the specific unit against the adopted budget, including whether any special assessment is running.
  • Milestone inspections and SIRS — cycles began decades ago; ask for the latest report. Built in 1969, Salem House's milestone inspections began around 1994 on the 25-year coastal rule and now run every ten years, with the most recent cycle around 2024 and the next around 2034 — derived dates, not confirmed — and the building turned 30 in 1999, so its structural integrity reserve study should already be complete. Ask the association for its most recent completed milestone report, its SIRS, the reserve study, and the last three years of board minutes before signing.
  • Subsidence — not on the study's list, which is a real positive. Salem House does not appear on the published list of 35 barrier-island buildings the University of Miami's 2024 InSAR study found settling between 2 and 8 centimeters from 2016 to 2023. The study's authors said no building was found unsafe, and the absence of Salem House from the list is a point in its favour, not a guarantee: ask the association whether any engineering review or monitoring has been done.
  • Reserves and assessments — unverified. No building-wide reserve figure or assessment history was found in public sources. Given the building's age, the reserve study and the last three years of board minutes are essential reading.
  • Owner-occupancy — low, and a lender will check it. County records show 17% of residences as owner-occupied, which points to an investor-heavy ownership base. If you are financing, confirm the current owner-occupancy ratio with the association before you are under contract, not after — some loan programs cap investor concentration.
  • Rentals — the rules genuinely conflict across sources; verify them in the association documents. The Raveis listing for unit #112 states "The building allows and approves short-term rentals, including Airbnb," and the 2025 listing for unit #209 states "this building and the city of sunny isles beach allows short term rental." But the MLS minimum-lease fields vary by unit: 360 days (unit #112), 365 days, 120 days with three leases a year (unit #132), and 180 days with two leases a year (unit #330) — while a rental listing for unit #321 requires a minimum six-month lease on an annual basis. Listing copy and MLS fields cannot both be right. Confirm the current lease rules — minimum stay, annual cap, approval process and fees — with the association in writing before buying for income.
  • Pets — mostly allowed with restrictions, per listing data, but not verified in an association document. Several MLS records state "Pets Allowed: Yes" with "Maximum 20 Lbs," rental listings state "Pets Allowed: 1" and "Pets allowed with restrictions," and one record states "Pet Restrictions: Restrictions Or Possible Restrictions." One old MLS record (tax year 2010) states "Pets Allowed: No," which appears outdated against the current records. Confirm the pet rule — size, number, breed limits, and any owner-versus-renter distinction — with the association in writing if a pet is part of the plan.

Who this building suits

Salem House suits a buyer who wants the lowest-priced way into Sunny Isles Beach — a one-bedroom of 564 square feet from about $282,000 to $290,000, with a community pool, laundry facilities, and one assigned parking space, one block from the beach — and who is comfortable doing the diligence a 1969 building demands: read the milestone report, the SIRS, and the reserve study before signing, and confirm the rental rules, the pet rule, and the dues for the specific unit in writing. It is a poor fit for a buyer who wants direct oceanfront, a larger residence, a full amenity program, a newer building, or firm rental and pet answers from public sources — the beach is a block away, every residence is a small one-bedroom or studio, the ownership base is investor-heavy, and the rental rules conflict across sources. If you are choosing between this and another tower, send Mike the buildings you are comparing and he will walk through the finances with you, building by building.

Next step

If Salem House is on your shortlist, start with the free Sunny Isles Beach Buyer's Building Guide. It walks through the checks that matter before you sign — milestone inspections, reserves, assessments, owner-occupancy, and the questions to ask any association.

Download the free guide: https://ultraluxrealty.com/sunny-isles-beach-buyers-guide

Book a call with Mike: https://calendar.app.google/YHekwSmZ7dWttvSu8

Contact Mike

Call or text: (305) 429-5420

Email: info@ultraluxrealty.com

Book a call: https://calendar.app.google/YHekwSmZ7dWttvSu8

Tell Mike what you're looking for — he'll get back to you shortly.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

Buying, selling, or renting starts with the right conversation.

Contact Mike