Ultra Lux Realty

Lux South Florida Real Estate

The White-Glove Standard in Lux Real Estate Based in Sunny Isles Beach, delivering exceptional buying, selling, leasing, and property management services across South Florida.

Poinciana Island, Sunny Isles Beach: What Buyers Should Check

Poinciana Island, Sunny Isles Beach — gated island townhomes and condos at 258 Poinciana Island Dr

Poinciana Island is not a tower at all — it is a private, guard-gated island community on the Intracoastal Waterway at the far north end of Sunny Isles Beach, built in 1980, with 190 waterfront townhomes and condo residences spread across a number of low- and mid-rise structures (the tallest is six stories). The island sits on a canal off the Intracoastal, directly across from Oleta River State Park, with private dockage and no fixed bridges between the island and the open bay — and the trade for giving up a high-rise tower is space: two-story townhomes of 2,265 to 2,830 square feet with private garages, in three- to five-bedroom layouts that have recently sold from about $801,000 to $1,145,000, inside gates with two pools, tennis courts, a gym, a clubhouse, and 24-hour security. The complication is the price of admission beyond the purchase: monthly dues run about $1,500 to $1,677 on the units checked, with one listing at $2,503, and the rental and pet rules rest on listing copy and directory entries rather than association documents — one current listing says pets up to 100 pounds and renting three times a year, while no written lease rule was found in public sources. One naming trap worth knowing: a lease-application document found online for a "Poinciana Condominium Association" belongs to a different Poinciana in Coral Springs, not this community, so its one-year-minimum and 25-pound pet rules do not apply here.

The facts

  • Address: 258 Poinciana Island Dr, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160 (association address: 350 Poinciana Dr).
  • Completed: 1980 (every source agrees — MLS records, directories, county subdivision records).
  • Stories: up to 6 (the tallest structures); the community is a mix of two-story townhomes and multi-story condo buildings, not a single tower.
  • Residences: 190. One aggregator page shows 192 — not corroborated.
  • Developer: not verified in any public source checked.
  • Architect: not verified in any public source checked.
  • Unit mix: three- to five-bedroom townhomes and condos, about 2,265–2,830 sq ft (3BR ~2,265 sq ft; 4BR ~2,425–2,650 sq ft; 5BR up to 3,115 sq ft). Most units checked are two-story townhomes with private garages.
  • Waterfront: island community on a canal off the Intracoastal Waterway, facing Oleta River State Park; private dockage with direct ocean access and no fixed bridges, per listings. The beach is across Collins Avenue, a short walk east.
  • Parking: private garage per townhome (1–2 cars) plus open-air parking, per listings.
  • Association: Poinciana Island Yacht & Racquet Club Condo Association, 350 Poinciana Dr, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160, (305) 947-2111. Sunbiz: Poinciana Island Yacht and Racquet Club Condominium Association, Inc., filed June 2, 1980, ACTIVE.

Amenities and day-to-day living

Poinciana Island runs a resort-style program behind its gate: two swimming pools, a heated pool and hot tub, tennis courts, a gym, a clubhouse, 24-hour security, on-site management, and private boat slips and dockage on the canal, with some units carrying deeded slips for vessels up to 40 feet. Dues include building insurance, water, HD cable, and internet, plus common areas, ground maintenance, structural maintenance, pest control, security, trash, and pool upkeep. The market is active for a community this size: 11 sales in the last twelve months, with recent closings including #208 (2,265 sq ft) at $801,000, #302 (2,650 sq ft) at $900,000 in September 2026, #903 (2,265 sq ft) at $955,000, #409 (2,650 sq ft) at $1,013,225, and #1215 sold November 20, 2025. As of mid-November 2026, about 10 units were for sale, asking from $839,000 (#1225, a split-level condo with a deeded 40-foot boat slip) to $1,699,000 (#1710, a 5-bedroom, 3,115 sq ft residence on one of the largest lots, with private dockage for two boats, listed as needing substantial renovation). Rentals are happening — a furnished townhome was listed at $7,500 a month, one unit rented at $6,000 a month in 2024, and another was tenant-occupied at $9,500 a month. The island sits minutes from Haulover Park, Aventura Mall, and Bal Harbour Shops.

What to check before you buy

  • (1) Monthly cost — the dues are high and vary widely by unit; confirm them per unit. Listing examples: $1,500 a month on #909 (2,425 sq ft), $1,601 a month on #1215, and $1,677 a month on #231 (2,265 sq ft) — about $0.62 to $0.74 per square foot. One listing for #1225 (401 Poinciana Dr) shows $2,503 a month, far above the others; that unit carries a deeded boat slip, and whether the slip explains the gap was not verified. Dues include building insurance, water, HD cable, and internet, plus common areas, ground maintenance, structural maintenance, pest control, security, trash, and pool upkeep (hot water and recreation facilities are listed as included on some units). Confirm the dues for the specific unit against the adopted budget, including whether any special assessment is running.
  • (2) Milestone inspections — cycles began decades ago; ask for the latest report. Built in 1980, Poinciana Island's first milestone inspection fell around 2005 on the 25-year coastal rule, with 10-year cycles since (around 2015 and 2025) — derived dates, not confirmed. Ask the association for its most recent completed milestone report and its Structural Integrity Reserve Study (SIRS). No verified milestone report or certification was found in public sources.
  • (3) Subsidence — not on the study's list, which is a real positive. Poinciana Island does not appear on the published list of 35 barrier-island buildings the University of Miami's 2024 InSAR study found settling between 2 and 8 centimeters from 2016 to 2023. The study's authors said no building was found unsafe, and the absence of Poinciana Island from the list is a point in its favour, not a guarantee: ask the association whether any engineering review or monitoring has been done.
  • (4) Reserves and assessments — unverified. No building-wide reserve figure or assessment history was found in public sources. One current listing claims "new roof, solid reserves, low HOA, no assessments" — that is listing copy, not an association document. Given the community's age and the dues level, the reserve study and the last three years of board minutes are essential reading.
  • (5) Owner-occupancy — unverified. No owner-occupancy ratio was found in public sources. If you are financing, your lender will check it — confirm it before you are under contract, not after.
  • (6) Rentals — happening, but the written rules were not verified. Rentals are visibly listed at $6,000–$9,500 a month, and one current listing states "rent 3x/year." No rental minimum, annual cap, waiting period, or approval process was verified in an association document in public sources. Do not rely on the Coral Springs document: a lease-application PDF found online for a "Poinciana Condominium Association" belongs to a different Poinciana at 11784 W. Sample Road, Coral Springs — its one-year minimum, once-a-year, and 25-pound pet rules do not apply to this community. Confirm the current lease rules with the association before buying for income.
  • (7) Pets — allowed, with a size limit mentioned in listing copy only. Directory entries record "Pets Allowed," and one record notes a pet size limit. One current listing states "Pets up to 100 lbs." No pet policy — size, number, or breed limits, or any owner-versus-renter distinction — was verified in an association document in public sources. Confirm against the association rules if a pet is part of the plan.

Who this building suits

Poinciana Island suits a buyer who wants the closest thing to a single-family waterfront home inside a Sunny Isles Beach condo — a two-story townhome of 2,265 to 2,830 square feet with a private garage, on a gated island with two pools, tennis, a gym, and private dockage with no fixed bridges to the open bay — and who is comfortable with dues around $1,500 a month and doing the diligence a 1980 community demands: read the milestone report, the reserve study, and the assessment history, and confirm the dues, rental, and pet rules for the specific unit before signing. It is a poor fit for a buyer who wants a high-rise tower, direct oceanfront, low dues, or firm rental answers from public sources — this is a low-rise island community, the beach is across Collins Avenue, and the rental rules rest on listing copy rather than association documents. If you are choosing between this and another tower, send Mike the buildings you are comparing and he will walk through the finances with you, building by building.

Next step

If Poinciana Island is on your shortlist, start with the free Sunny Isles Beach Buyer's Building Guide. It walks through the checks that matter before you sign — milestone inspections, reserves, assessments, owner-occupancy, and the questions to ask any association. Download the free guide: https://ultraluxrealty.com/sunny-isles-beach-buyers-guide — Book a call with Mike: https://calendar.app.google/YHekwSmZ7dWttvSu8

Contact Mike

Call or text: (305) 429-5420

Email: info@ultraluxrealty.com

Book a call: https://calendar.app.google/YHekwSmZ7dWttvSu8

Tell Mike what you're looking for — he'll get back to you shortly.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

Buying, selling, or renting starts with the right conversation.

Contact Mike