Sunny Isles Beach is a condo city — out of 19,666 housing units, only about 424 are detached single-family houses, roughly 2.2% (U.S. Census, American Community Survey 2020–2024). Poinciana Island is not one of those detached-house neighborhoods, and this post will not pretend otherwise: it is a private, guard-gated island of waterfront townhomes and condos. It belongs in this series because buyers shopping for a house in Sunny Isles Beach will be shown it — and for many of them, it is the closest thing to house living they can buy here.

Where it is
Poinciana Island sits at 258 Poinciana Island Drive, between Atlantic Island and Arlen House, on the bay side of Sunny Isles Beach. The community is the Poinciana Island Yacht & Racquet Club, built in 1980–1981, with about 190–200 units — sources differ on the exact count (190 vs. 200), so the range is shown.
The island is framed by the greenery of Oleta River State Park across the water. The beach is across the street, a short walk east across Collins Avenue.
What the homes are like
The stock is two-story townhomes and midrise condominiums — no detached houses. Townhomes are typically 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and about 2,220–2,500 square feet; one listing describes 2,265 square feet with vaulted ceilings and a private garage.
What sets Poinciana Island apart:
- Private, guard-gated island with 24-hour security
- Clubhouse, tennis courts, two pools, gym, and racquetball court
- Beach access across the street
- Many residences include deeded docks up to 40 feet, with direct, bridge-free ocean access through Haulover Inlet
That combination — a townhome layout with a garage, a private dock, and a gated island setting — is why house shoppers end up here even though nothing on the island is a detached house.
What it costs — verified figures only
- 4 homes sold in the six months to November 10, 2026, at a median $935,000 ($413/sq ft), 89.5% of asking, average 100 days on market; 8 for sale (BeachesMLS via BreakThru Realty).
- Example closing: 300 Poinciana Dr Unit 702, a townhouse, sold December 17, 2025 — 4 bedrooms plus den, 3 baths, with a 43-foot dock.
No verified association or HOA fee for Poinciana Island is stated here, because fees vary by unit and no single verified figure was found. If a listing quotes a fee, verify it in writing for that specific unit before an offer.
What to check before you buy here
- Townhome or condo — and which documents govern it — Poinciana Island mixes townhomes and condominiums. Get the declaration, rules, and budget for the specific unit, not just the community brochure.
- Dock rights for that exact unit — dock rights differ from unit to unit. Confirm in writing whether a slip is deeded, assigned, or shared, its length, and whether it transfers with the sale. A listing that says "dock" is not the document.
- Association fees and reserves — get the current budget, financial statement, and any special assessment history for that unit's association in writing. No verified neighborhood-wide fee figure exists, so do not rely on a generic number.
- Milestone inspection and SIRS status — the buildings date to 1980–1981, so ask for the milestone inspection report and the structural integrity reserve study (SIRS), and how required repairs are being funded.
- Flood zone and elevation — check the FEMA map for the specific building and get the elevation certificate; waterfront island property needs its own flood check, lot by lot and building by building.
- Rental and pet rules — verify the association's rental minimum, approval process, and pet rules in writing before buying as an investor or with a pet.
Who Poinciana Island suits
Buyers who want house-like living — a townhome floor plan, a private garage, a dock, and a gated island setting — without detached-house pricing in Sunny Isles Beach, and who understand they are buying into a townhome/condo association, with its rules, fees, and reserve obligations, not a standalone house.